Are Speeding Cameras In Chicago Another Example Of Big Brother

The Chicago Tribune reported this week that Chicago Mayor, Rham Emanuel, is pushing forward with full steam a state law that would allow cameras to catch drivers speeding through school areas and other spots with high pedestrian traffic. The proposal, which has already passed the state Senate, would allow the city to issue $100 tickets if caught speeding on camera.

Mayor Emanuel has stated that the only reason for the fast action on this measure is to protect pedestrians,  "my goal is only one thing, the safety of our kids."

Despite the the noble stated purpose by Emanuel and his administration, there are numerous critics asking the question as to whether these cameras are necessary.  Multiple sceptics wonder if speeding is the actual cause for most vehicle-pedestrian accidents in Chicago.

Arguing for cameras, Emanuel has stressed statistics from a recent federally funded pedestrian study showing that over the five-year period  (2005-2009), there were 861 crashes near schools that involved school-age children and occurred roughly around arrival and dismissal times. Those car crashes resulted in three deaths and 115 serious injuries, according to the study.

The report, however, did not analyze whether speeding was a contributing factor to those vechicle accidents, making it difficult to project how many might have been avoided if speed cameras had been in place.

Chicago officials acknowledge they have no studies that correlate speeding with car accidents involving children. Instead, they point to a body of federal reports showing that speeding contributes to a significant number of crashes, and the peril to pedestrians increases the faster cars go.  

So the question remains (as with the red light cameras installed a few years ago), will the speeding cameras actually make the streets of Chicago safer? Are these pedestrian accidents occurring because of speeders, or are they due to other factors such texting and driving, drinking and driving or other distracted driving factors.

Other critics have mentioned that since the cameras are only being installed in the city, they cost will be bourn upon those who can least afford it.  Also, is this another example of Chicago acting as Big Brother and intruding into the lives of its' residents?

It will be interested to see after the law passes and the cameras are installed whether pedestrian accidents in these areas actually goes down.

If you or someone you love has been involved in a Chicago car accident or a Chicago vehicle-pedestrian accident, then call Chicago personal injury lawyer Aaron Bryant for a free consultation at 312-5988-3384 or go to the firm website at www.blgchicago.com.

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments
  • No comments exist for this post.
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Enter the above security code (required)

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.